different competitions

Everything about the contests

different competitions

Messaggioda rakesh_rai » mer 20 lug 2011, 8:06

Argio is a great site and we can look forward to a good competition every week here. And there is a lot of variety too. I thought let me share some views on them (not from a criticism point of view but from a constructive viewpoint):

(1) Contest and Roulette: I do not think both look much different now. I know the difference between the two - in one you carefully select grids according to the points and in the other, it is the luck factor which chooses the grids. But should both of them co-exist, or just one would be fine? These are definitely the oldest competitions around on your site and are popular too.

(2) Headshrinker: Personally, this is my favourite. Recently, we have seen a lot of easy grids appear on this contest, which is the only thing I did
not like. Always look forward to this one.

(3) Classics only: I am not a fan of classics, never was. But there may be others who like it.

(4) Hybrids: I, for some reason, am not liking hybrids. And the grids used in hybrids are almost the same set everytime - 2evenodd, offset, knight, untouch, nonconsecutive etc. For me, it becomes too much to solve too many such grids at a time - maybe this is a problem specific to me. But I just checked and the average participation for hybrids is ~51 which is significantly less than your other competitions. So there are others too who are giving hybrids a pass. I am unsure if this should be a regular competition or not.

I would be happy if any of the above comments helps Argio improve further in some way.
rakesh_rai
 
Messaggi: 176
Iscritto il: gio 30 lug 2009, 16:27
Località: Pune, India

Re: different competitions

Messaggioda gabriele » mer 20 lug 2011, 10:36

Thanks, Rajesh
I share many of yours points.
I wish other users could express their point of view in order to improve, if possible, our site.
Il genere umano è diviso in 10 specie: quella che capisce il binario e quella che non lo capisce
Avatar utente
gabriele
Amministratore
 
Messaggi: 4605
Iscritto il: dom 13 apr 2008, 11:27
Località: porto mantovano

Re: different competitions

Messaggioda Fred76 » ven 22 lug 2011, 23:49

As Rakesh says, this site offers an opportunity to participate in a sudoku tournament every weekend, which is great!

From my point of view, the biggest area for improvement is the number of points assigned to each grid. It often does not reflect the real difficulty of the grids.
For example, the grid "4 box" has often the highest number of points, but is clearly not the most difficult of the contest, and is often solved by many players in under 10 minutes. It would be interesting that some players test the grids before the tournament and that the points awarded are reflecting their timings and comments.

From my point of view, 2h30 is a bit too long for a tournament. I would prefer a period of 2 hours.

The tournament Headshrinker is interesting, but times (and ranking) are almost anecdotal to me. The important thing is to find a logical path that allows me to solve each grid, especially the hardest, it makes me grow. It is very rare that I conceded to an hypothesis to save time. As Rakesh says, sometimes there are too easy grids to deserve the "label headshrinker".

I like hybrids grids. Here hybrids come from 2 "classic twins" grids, which is perhaps not the hybrids I prefer. After 4-5 grids, It becomes difficult to stay focused and sometimes, for a few seconds, I do not know what grid I'm trying to solve.
Hybrids grids I prefer are a mixture between a classic twin (nonconsecutive, antiknight, 2even2odd, queen, untouch,...) and a variant with other clues (diagonal, killer, jigsaw, consecutive, skyscrapers, outside, frame, 4 box or anything else).


Fred ;)
Fred76
 
Messaggi: 82
Iscritto il: lun 19 ott 2009, 21:40

Re: different competitions

Messaggioda gabriele » sab 23 lug 2011, 12:52

I will definitely take note of your comments and try all my best to improve.
This will take some time to find some solutions.
I can give immediate answer to some comments:
contest time
many times i thought to reduce the time, but I reached the conclusion that it is not so important.
what is the difference if the user X finish the tournament at 270 points in 2 hours or 300 points in 2:28
on the other side many second level players may have their satisfaction to reach the maximum in 2:30, no matter if the best has closed in 1:20

pre testing the grids
I can't test the grids because I'm very bad in solving
I used the daily solvers times as system to evaluate the difficulty of the grid, realising that they are not reliable
Pre-testing is good only if the test is done by a champion, like in the other international contest.
I don't know who I can ask.
I prefere that champions play the contest rather then testing it.
Il genere umano è diviso in 10 specie: quella che capisce il binario e quella che non lo capisce
Avatar utente
gabriele
Amministratore
 
Messaggi: 4605
Iscritto il: dom 13 apr 2008, 11:27
Località: porto mantovano

Roulette Statistics

Messaggioda gabriele » lun 25 lug 2011, 16:55

here the average solution time of first 10 solvers.

Immagine

as a consequence the relevant points will be rescheduled as follows

Immagine
Il genere umano è diviso in 10 specie: quella che capisce il binario e quella che non lo capisce
Avatar utente
gabriele
Amministratore
 
Messaggi: 4605
Iscritto il: dom 13 apr 2008, 11:27
Località: porto mantovano

Neighbours Bug

Messaggioda gabriele » lun 25 lug 2011, 17:51

Found and corrected a bug in the "Neighbours" generator.
The bug caused the wrong evaluation in the grid of the last headshrinker (solved in 2:42)
Il genere umano è diviso in 10 specie: quella che capisce il binario e quella che non lo capisce
Avatar utente
gabriele
Amministratore
 
Messaggi: 4605
Iscritto il: dom 13 apr 2008, 11:27
Località: porto mantovano

Anti Knight

Messaggioda gabriele » gio 28 lug 2011, 12:18

I wondered why the anti.knight was always resolved with fast times.
the answer was because the generator was limited to elementary situations.
I have now modified the routine.
how do you evaluate this grid?

Il genere umano è diviso in 10 specie: quella che capisce il binario e quella che non lo capisce
Avatar utente
gabriele
Amministratore
 
Messaggi: 4605
Iscritto il: dom 13 apr 2008, 11:27
Località: porto mantovano

Re: different competitions

Messaggioda emilio » gio 28 lug 2011, 15:06

tosto, ma senza tentativi. Solo ragionamento, come piace a me (alla fine tutti quei 4-7-9-1 che si intrecciavano, mi hanno dato molto da pensare, ma la sequenza giusta si riesce a trovarla)
Risolto in una ventina di minuti (10 prima di pranzo, 10 dopo)
:ok :ok :ok
il Sudoku è un gioco che va meditato. Correte piano
EMILIO
Avatar utente
emilio
 
Messaggi: 3906
Iscritto il: dom 7 mar 2010, 19:24
Località: monza

Re: different competitions

Messaggioda rakesh_rai » gio 28 lug 2011, 15:38

Fred76 ha scritto:I like hybrids grids. Here hybrids come from 2 "classic twins" grids, which is perhaps not the hybrids I prefer. After 4-5 grids, It becomes difficult to stay focused and sometimes, for a few seconds, I do not know what grid I'm trying to solve.
Hybrids grids I prefer are a mixture between a classic twin (nonconsecutive, antiknight, 2even2odd, queen, untouch,...) and a variant with other clues (diagonal, killer, jigsaw, consecutive, skyscrapers, outside, frame, 4 box or anything else).


I wanted to write exactly the same thing about how I felt after 4-5 grids. Otherwise, the views on hybrids are very nicely put, Fred. And I would agree with it.
rakesh_rai
 
Messaggi: 176
Iscritto il: gio 30 lug 2009, 16:27
Località: Pune, India

Re: different competitions

Messaggioda gabriele » gio 28 lug 2011, 18:17

rakesh_rai ha scritto:
Fred76 ha scritto:I like hybrids grids. Here hybrids come from 2 "classic twins" grids, which is perhaps not the hybrids I prefer. After 4-5 grids, It becomes difficult to stay focused and sometimes, for a few seconds, I do not know what grid I'm trying to solve.
Hybrids grids I prefer are a mixture between a classic twin (nonconsecutive, antiknight, 2even2odd, queen, untouch,...) and a variant with other clues (diagonal, killer, jigsaw, consecutive, skyscrapers, outside, frame, 4 box or anything else).


I wanted to write exactly the same thing about how I felt after 4-5 grids. Otherwise, the views on hybrids are very nicely put, Fred. And I would agree with it.


I understand, I will study something
in the meantime for the next I could propose

2even-Offset
2even-Queen
Knight-Nonconsecutive
Knight-Untouch
Nonconsecutive-Untouch
Offset-Queen
X Frame
Killer Diagonal
Iso Mini Killer
Rossini Outside
Jigsaw Consecutive
Il genere umano è diviso in 10 specie: quella che capisce il binario e quella che non lo capisce
Avatar utente
gabriele
Amministratore
 
Messaggi: 4605
Iscritto il: dom 13 apr 2008, 11:27
Località: porto mantovano

Re: Anti Knight

Messaggioda Fred76 » gio 28 lug 2011, 19:17

gabriele ha scritto:I wondered why the anti.knight was always resolved with fast times.
the answer was because the generator was limited to elementary situations.
I have now modified the routine.
how do you evaluate this grid?



Nice grid, I liked it !

I solved it in about 9 minutes
Fred76
 
Messaggi: 82
Iscritto il: lun 19 ott 2009, 21:40

Re: Anti Knight

Messaggioda gabriele » gio 28 lug 2011, 21:09

Fred76 ha scritto:Nice grid, I liked it !

I solved it in about 9 minutes

thanks Fred,
your solving times are very usefull to me
I hope to submit to your evalaution another hybrid in a short time
I'm working at outsisde+anti diagonal
Il genere umano è diviso in 10 specie: quella che capisce il binario e quella che non lo capisce
Avatar utente
gabriele
Amministratore
 
Messaggi: 4605
Iscritto il: dom 13 apr 2008, 11:27
Località: porto mantovano

Outside + Anti Diagonal

Messaggioda gabriele » ven 29 lug 2011, 12:54

Il genere umano è diviso in 10 specie: quella che capisce il binario e quella che non lo capisce
Avatar utente
gabriele
Amministratore
 
Messaggi: 4605
Iscritto il: dom 13 apr 2008, 11:27
Località: porto mantovano

Skyscraper Anti XV

Messaggioda gabriele » mar 2 ago 2011, 16:10

Il genere umano è diviso in 10 specie: quella che capisce il binario e quella che non lo capisce
Avatar utente
gabriele
Amministratore
 
Messaggi: 4605
Iscritto il: dom 13 apr 2008, 11:27
Località: porto mantovano

Re: different competitions

Messaggioda Fred76 » gio 4 ago 2011, 16:40

Hard grids !

22 minutes for the outside anti-diagonal and 18 minutes for the skyscrapers anti-XV.
Good hybrids, I like these combinations ;)

Fred
Fred76
 
Messaggi: 82
Iscritto il: lun 19 ott 2009, 21:40

Re: different competitions

Messaggioda gabriele » gio 18 ago 2011, 19:14

Il genere umano è diviso in 10 specie: quella che capisce il binario e quella che non lo capisce
Avatar utente
gabriele
Amministratore
 
Messaggi: 4605
Iscritto il: dom 13 apr 2008, 11:27
Località: porto mantovano

Re: Anti Knight

Messaggioda sisi59 » sab 20 ago 2011, 22:49

I test the Antiknight grid : 5 minutes to solve it.
sisi59
 
Messaggi: 17
Iscritto il: mar 29 dic 2009, 16:26


Torna a Contest

Chi c’è in linea

Visitano il forum: Nessuno e 45 ospiti